c44477dea0
gather → reviewers(並列5) → supervise → COMPLETE のフローで、PR情報とリンクIssueを収集後、 5つの専門レビュワーが並列にレビューし、supervisorが統合サマリーを出力する。 review-only と review-fix-minimal は pr-review に置き換えて削除。
1.1 KiB
1.1 KiB
Review the changes from a requirements fulfillment perspective.
Review criteria:
- Whether each requested requirement has been implemented
- Whether implicit requirements (naturally expected behaviors) are satisfied
- Whether changes outside the scope (scope creep) have crept in
- Whether there are any partial or missing implementations
Previous finding tracking (required):
- First, extract open findings from "Previous Response"
- Assign
finding_idto each finding and classify current status asnew / persists / resolved - If status is
persists, provide concrete unresolved evidence (file/line)
Judgment Procedure
- Extract requirements one by one from the PR description and task
- For each requirement, identify the implementing code (file:line)
- Confirm that the code satisfies the requirement
- Check for any changes not covered by the requirements
- For each detected issue, classify as blocking/non-blocking based on Policy's scope determination table and judgment rules
- If there is even one blocking issue (
neworpersists), judge as REJECT