555 B

The ai_review (reviewer) and ai_fix (coder) disagree.

  • ai_review flagged issues and issued a REJECT
  • ai_fix reviewed and determined "no fix needed"

Review both outputs and arbitrate which judgment is valid.

Reports to reference:

  • AI review results: {report:ai-review.md}

Judgment criteria:

  • Whether ai_review's findings are specific and point to real issues in the code
  • Whether ai_fix's rebuttal has evidence (file verification results, test results)
  • Whether the findings are non-blocking (record only) level or actually require fixes